Solid Growth in Global Auto Sales but US Protectionism May Stall Further Gains Juan Manuel Herrera, Scotiabank Economics, July 2018

Image result for auto sales image

STRONG EXPANSION IN GLOBAL SALES 

Global auto sales expanded by 4.6% y/y in May, bringing the year-to-date total growth rate to 3.4% y/y, in line with the increase recorded during the same period in the previous two years. The growth in sales thus far in 2018 has, as expected, been led by strong gains in developing economies while a number of advanced economies have reached sales plateaux, albeit near record levels. The global economy remains strong amid a mutually reinforcing expansion brought about by rising trade flows across the world. An escalation of US protectionism, however, threatens to slow the pace of global growth.

NORTH AMERICA: US AND CANADA PLATEAU, MEXICO EXTENDS DECLINE

The Canadian and US auto markets remain slightly below record-high sales levels, amidst slowing, but still solid, household consumption growth. Both countries have reported auto sales figures at the national level for June, which showed a year-on-year decline of 1.7% in Canada and a strong 4.7% y/y expansion in the US, which handily beat analysts’ expectations of a 2.4% y/y uptick. In the first half of 2018, vehicle purchases climbed by 0.3% y/y in Canada and 1.1% y/y in the US compared to the same period last year, though sales volumes are still down slightly from late-2017 levels. Sales are forecast to decline for the remainder of the year, but still come in slightly above 2.0 mn and 17.0 mn units sold in Canada and the US, respectively. This would represent a marginal decline from record-high sales of 2.04 mn in 2017 in Canada and 17.5 mn in 2016 in the US. Rising interest rates, in combination with higher gasoline prices, are set to scale back discretionary spending in H2-2018 and 2019.

At the provincial level in Canada, a slight increase in purchases in Central Canada has been offset by sales declines in Western and Atlantic Canada so far in 2018. Based on figures to May, sales have fallen year-to-date (YTD) in each of the Atlantic Provinces for a regional decline of 7.7% y/y. Purchases in Western Canada are down by 1.1% y/y YTD during the same period after four consecutive months of year-on-year declines. Sales in the West have fallen recently due to a retracement of purchases in Alberta—which climbed sharply following the commodities collapse and wildfire-related vehicle replacements—and an easing in BC sales from record-high levels in 2017. In contrast, vehicle sales in Central Canada have risen by 1% in the year-to-May compared to the same period last year, bolstered by solid growth in Quebec and Ontario.

Political uncertainty in Mexico dampened purchases of vehicles in the lead-up to the Presidential election on July 1st, with a year-to-May decrease of 8.8% y/y. Sales in Mexico are expected to bounce back in the second half of 2018, which would bring the annual decline to around 2% y/y in 2018 as a whole.

EUROPE: UK DEPRESSES WESTERN EUROPE SALES, RUSSIA LIFTS THE EAST

Sales declines in the United Kingdom have been large enough to drag down the growth rate of vehicle purchases in Western Europe so far in 2018. Auto purchases in the UK have fallen by 6.8% y/y year-to-May amidst dampened economic growth brought on by Brexit uncertainty, and further compounded by adverse weather conditions. In comparison, vehicle purchases in the rest of Western Europe have advanced by 3.2% y/y year-to-date. Auto sales in the UK may have reached their cyclical trough as year-onyear increases in both April and May put an end to a twelve-month streak of annual declines. Looking ahead, the UK economy is forecast to grow by about 1.7% y/y, around its long-term trend, which implies any further auto sales gains should be moderate. In contrast, we expect Eurozone GDP to grow at a stronger pace of 2.5% in 2018, which should support further sales increases.

In Eastern Europe, a surge in auto sales in Russia has pushed growth in vehicle purchases in the region to 12% y/y in the first five months of 2018 over the same period last year. Auto sales in Russia alone have expanded by 20% y/y YTD after an 18% y/y rise in May which marked eighteen consecutive months of double-digit gains thanks to an economic rebound from the recovery in oil prices. The number of units sold in Russia remains around 40% lower than its 2012 peak, however. Sales in the rest of Eastern Europe have climbed by a strong 6.3% y/y so far in 2018, although they ticked down 1.2% y/y in May.

SOUTH AMERICA: BRAZIL AND CHILE POST LARGE GAINS

Auto purchases in South America are expanding by double digits in year-on-year terms in the first five months of 2018 led by Brazil and Chile. Sales in Brazil, the largest auto market on the continent, have risen by 16% y/y YTD in 2018 as the country leaves behind the 2015–16 recession and weak economic growth in 2017. However, business uncertainty leading into the October presidential elections and an erosion in disposable income owing to high interest rates and relatively-high inflation are set to tamp down the sales expansion in the second half of 2018; the 2.6% y/y rise in sales in May was the lowest since July 2017. Auto purchases in Chile have spiked by 25% y/y so far in 2018. We forecast the Chilean economy to rebound strongly postelection and grow by 3.7% in 2018, more than double the 1.5% pace set in 2017. Continent-wide vehicle deliveries in South America expanded by 2.2% y/y in May for a year-to-date rise of 14% y/y.

ASIA-PACIFIC: CHINA LEADS THE WAY, JAPANESE SALES REMAIN WEAK

A strong rise in auto purchases in China in recent months has lifted sales across the Asia-Pacific region, which follows a weak performance for the sector in late-2017 and through the Chinese New Year period in February. After averaging only 0.6% y/y growth in the October–February period, vehicle sales in China expanded by an average of 8.3% y/y in the March–May stretch, which is more in line with the ongoing rise in household incomes in the country. On the other hand, sales in Japan, the second largest market in the region, have declined slightly so far in 2018 in year-on-year terms as the pace of economic expansion in the country throttles back closer to its long-run potential. While the latest pick-up in Chinese auto sales—at 9.2% y/y in May— contributed to a region-wide 7.5% y/y increase in May, purchases in Asia Pacific excluding China rose by 4.6% y/y. Year-to-date, total sales in the region have expanded by 4.2% y/y.

US AUTO TARIFFS: GERMAN AUTOMAKERS WOULD BE HIT HARDEST, BIG THREE DO NOT ESCAPE UNHARMED

The US Administration has threatened to impose tariffs of up to 25% on US imports of motor vehicles and parts. Following the application of tariffs on steel and aluminum imports, President Trump has requested an investigation into the national security implications of imports of autos and parts. Global tariffs on US auto imports would likely be the first step in an escalation of tit-fortat retaliatory measures by affected nations which would lead to a trade war that would push the US economy into recession by 2020—right before the next US presidential elections. As such, our baseline remains that they will not be imposed. The US is a net importer of automobiles and would encounter a gap of between 5 and 6mn units even if it stopped exporting vehicles altogether at current demand levels. In 2017, imports into the US amounted to 8.3 mn units compared to only 2.0 mn exported units. Close to half of autos imported into the US come from North America: Mexico and Canada account for roughly a quarter of all vehicles sold in the US annually. Imports from the European Union, whose 10% auto tariffs have been a principal target of the White House, represent 7% of autos sold in the US. Japan and Korea together account for 15%. Only around 1% of autos sold in the US come from other countries.

If the US imposes tariffs on all countries, but maintains duty-free trade under NAFTA, the biggest losers among the major automakers would be Mazda, Audi, BMW, and Daimler, whose imports from outside North America account for 82%, 77%, 71%, and 62% of their respective auto sales volumes in the US, in that order. The impact on the Detroit Three automakers would be relatively subdued since non-NAFTA imports are only around 5% of their combined sales in the US. Given the high number of vehicles assembled in Canada and Mexico, in addition to those built in the US, Honda would be the least affected of all non-US automakers: 93% of its sales in the US are autos assembled in North America.   An import tariff on all foreign autos, including those from Canada and Mexico, would impact a much larger swath of vehicles sold in the US, and would seriously hurt the Detroit Three firms. Beyond the automakers mentioned in the previous paragraph, some companies with large manufacturing operations in Canada and/or Mexico would lose their free-trade advantage under NAFTA. The share of Fiat-Chrysler autos sold in the US affected by the tariffs would go from 7% in an ex. Canada and Mexico scenario to around 54% of their sales if the US also imposes tariffs on its NAFTA partners. For General Motors, this share would climb from 6.3% to 37%. Ford would see tariffs on about a fifth of its US-sold vehicles compared to only 1%. Volkswagen could go from facing double-digit tariffs on only about 11% of the vehicles it sells in the US to almost 75% of its US sales falling under tariffs owing to the large number of autos the company assembles in Mexico for the US market.

If tariffs were imposed on all motor vehicle imports, German automakers, as a whole, would be hit hardest with around three quarters of their US-sold autos subject to the tariffs, followed by Korean firms at around 55%, and Japanese companies at roughly half. The Detroit Three firms would nevertheless face tariffs on over a third of their autos sold in US markets based on 2017 levels. In the still-unlikely scenario where the US imposes tariffs on motor vehicle imports from all countries there could be a significant rebalancing of market share toward firms with the highest vehicle production volumes in the US: namely the Big Three, Honda, Toyota and Nissan.

The vehicle assembly industry in the US is, however, operating at close to its full utilisation rate, which implies that auto production in the US would likely increase only marginally in response to the tariffs. The economic downturn that would result from retaliatory tariffs or an all-out trade-war-induced recession would keep firms from making significant outlays toward increasing capacity. In this scenario, sales are bound to heavily decrease amid rising prices for imported vehicles and depressed household expenditures.

Source:
https://www.scotiabank.com/content/dam/scotiabank/sub-brands/scotiabank-economics/english/documents/global-auto-report/GAR_2018-07-06.pdf

1 thought on “Solid Growth in Global Auto Sales but US Protectionism May Stall Further Gains Juan Manuel Herrera, Scotiabank Economics, July 2018

  • Hello there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after checking through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Anyhow, I’m definitely glad I found it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back often!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *